The ladder vs. spiral model for language learning

How we conceptualize our language learning deeply affects our attitudes and success in language learning. Many of us have – whether we are aware of it or not – adopted a ladder or “video games” model of acquiring a new language. This language learning process is divided into numerous levels. To move to the next level, you need to successfully graduate from the level before. In mathematics at school, it doesn't make sense to move forward before a student has grasped the basic tenets of arithmetic.

But, is this a valid approach to learning a language? At first glance, much in the language teaching industry seems to reinforce such a model. Language proficiency, courses and standardized tests follow bureaucratically-imposed levels (like the ABC levels in Europe). 

Whether intended or not, this often provokes unproductive attitudes and habits among students. Some curb their natural curiosity of playfully exploring the “territory” of a language: “I am still at A 1.2 level. This future tense stuff is not for me, yet.” Here, we have a handy pretext for procrastination, rationalized by the perceived opinions of language experts.

Others become afraid that exposing themselves to more “advanced” grammar will somehow sabotage their efforts in understanding the “basic” stuff. Thus, they can even become hostile to a teacher who is trying to familiarize the students with other grammar topics, not included in the official textbook.

The problem with language learning is that it differs fundamentally from mathematics or computer games where 100% understanding and performance is doable. What would solving a “language level” at 100% mean: knowing all irregular verbs first, before moving on to pronouns; or knowing the right gender of all German/Swedish/Arabic nouns first, before learning the declension of adjectives?

The result of this is, that many language learners spend years in cycles of starting at level 1, then interrupting the process due to lack of time, and then restarting – maybe with a new textbook or teacher. Again, and again.

A better approach would be to conceptualize language learning as an upward spiral. At first, you superficially explore the whole territory of a new language: how many cases, tenses, word order rules, etc. does it have? What will the greatest obstacles be – according to advanced learners? And then moving slightly upward, periodically reviewing the various grammar topics and improving upon them in small increments.

This is more in tune with how we learned our native language. To use a metaphor, consider how you would plant a garden for a new house. You wouldn’t wait until the first oak tree had grown before planting bushes and flowers, or the other way around, would you?! Most probably, you would disperse the largest variety of seeds possible, and water and care for them during the next years. As with some trees, some grammar topics are inherently long-distance efforts. You wouldn’t get angry at an oak tree for not growing faster, would you? However, you would water it nonetheless from day 1.

What do you think? Leave a comment below.

--

Want to get rid of insecurity and bad feelings regarding the foreign language(s) you have already started to learn? Want to learn a new language, without going through various levels of standard courses? You feel you are making no progress?

Go to Amazon and grab a copy of my classic book ”The GO Method – breaking barriers to language learning”.

https://www.amazon.com/GO-Method-Breaking-barriers-language/dp/1973118688/ref=sr_1_1?crid=ZLMGYKR6PDY3&keywords=Gerhard+Ohrband&qid=1694099394&sprefix=gerhard+ohrband+%2Caps%2C239&sr=8-1

Get the first two chapters for free by subscribing to Gerhard's weekly newsletter, with advice and resources on selling in foreign languages. Just click here.

--

Do you feel a bit insecure when doing business internationally, maybe even in a foreign language?

Profit from new strategies, insights and techniques that will make you use foreign languages more successfully in international business communication.

Get rid of fear of mistakes and blocks during trade shows, presentation and sales calls.

Gerhard Ohrband is a communication consultant, psychologist and author of 9 books from Hamburg/Germany. He speaks 11 languages fluently and assists individuals and companies in doing business in foreign languages.

 

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why we need to train talking to bad people

Image
We live in a polarized world. Covid, migration, the Ukraine war, gender (and gender pronouns) or climate change: There is an ever-growing list of possibilities for division, for separating between our ingroup and the outgroup, between the good and the bad guys (and girls). Many of us simply refuse to speak to people with other opinions. We often hear this as an advice. You shouldn’t/cannot speak with evil people. Well, this is actually a very dangerous advice. The more we retreat from engaging in dialogue with people with other opinions and positions, the more vulnerable we become as communicators. This is one explanation why populist politicians are becoming so successful worldwide. Many establishment politicians have been living in a conversational bubble for years. They have been asked predictable and softball questions by more or less friendly journalists and colleagues. They have tried to build firewalls against their opponents. In short, they have relaxed the conversa...
Read more

10 situations you should practice in your language courses

Image
If you are familiar with contemporary language education, you will understand that practicing conversation during lessons is a key element for success. For previous generations, this was not the norm. Also due to classroom size and unprepared or insecure teachers, foreign language instruction relied heavily on pen and paper exercises. The result: excellent grades did not equal being able to talk freely. The next level is assessing how communication should be practiced. For many language learners, communication is just one homogenous block of activity. There are, however, considerable differences between ·         Preparing at home vs. reacting spontaneously ·         Talking to the teacher vs. communicating in small groups with other students ·         Focusing on playing it safe vs. experimenting with new ways of saying things ·      ...
Read more

5 proven ways to effectively self-sabotage your language learning

Image
In self-improvement and self-development, many of us have a hording or accumulative mentality: More skills, more life hacks, more insights. Often, the key is to just throw out mental clutter. As a psychologist myself, I am afraid to over-psychologize everything. Nonetheless, it is safe to say that more than 50% of our success of acquiring a new language depends on psychological issues: ·         Patience: Am I ready to wait years before expecting authentic fluency? ·         Self-discipline: Can I stick to a daily learning routine for more than 21 days? ·         Self-image: Do I really see myself as communicating fluently in foreign languages? ·         Risk-avoidance or tolerance: Am I willing to enter a conversation not being perfectly prepared? ·         Reactions to setbacks and failures: Should ...
Read more